Final Yield Results from PNW Winter and Spring Canola Variety Trials – 2018

 

 

Yield results of 2017-18 On-farm Winter Canola Variety Trials
Variety The Dalles1   Ritzvile2   Mansfield3  
  ————————– lbs/acre ——————————
Mercedes 3,049 a 3,130 a 2,445 a
Griffin 2,785 ab 3,034 a 1,652 a
HyClass 320 2,550 bc 2,583 a 1,929 a
Edimax CL  —-  —- 2,621 a 2,163 a
Amanda 2,494 bc 2,828 a 1,817 a
HyClass 225 2,333 c 2,642 a 1,796 a
Claremore 2,241 c 2,857 a 1,722 a
Mean 2,585 2,814 1,932  
Tukey HSD(0.05) 375 ns ns  
CV (%) 7.0 12.1 30.2  
1 Planted Sept. 22, 2017, harvested July 16 and July 23, 2018.

2 Planted Sept. 19, 2017, harvested July 21 and August 6, 2018.

3 Planted August 24, 2017, harvested 7/26/18.

Funding provided by Viterra, Inc. Seed provided by Croplan by Winfield, Kansas State University, Rubisco Seeds, Spectrum Crop Development, and University of Idaho.


 

Yield results of 2018 On-farm Spring Canola Variety Trials
Variety Ralston1   Reardan2   Walla Walla3  
  ————————– lbs/acre ——————————
NCC 101S 1,955 a 774 a 2,417 a
HyClass 930 1,864 ab 696 a 2,608 a
InVigor L233P 1,793 bc 693 a 2,433 a
BY 6080 RR 1,639 c 557 a 2,410 a
BY 5545 CL 1,694 c 529 a 2,319 ab
DG 200 CL 1,631 c 508 a 2,253 ab
HyClass 730 1,709 bc
Nexera 2024 CL 1,291 d 515 a 1,824   b
Mean 1,710 611 2323
Tukey HSD(0.05) 223 285 533
CV (%) 4.8 19.4 9.8
1 Planted April 9, harvested August 6

2 Planted May 11, harvested September 3

3 Planted March 30, harvested August 1

Funding provided by Viterra, Inc. Seed provided by Bayer CropScience, BrettYoung, Croplan, Dow AgroSciences, Nutrien Ag Solutions (formerly CPS) and Photosyntech.


 

2018 University of Idaho Pacific Northwest Winter Canola and Rapeseed Variety Trial results including mean yield (lbs. per acre) and rank across all sites, yield (lbs. per acre) and rank at individual locations, date of flower start (days from January 1, mean of Moscow and Genesee Early sites), and plant canopy height at maturity (inches, mean of Moscow and Genesee Early sites).

 

Mean of All Sites

Yield by Site

Odessa, WA Moscow, ID Genesee, ID-Early Genesee, ID-Late Pendleton, OR Hermiston, OR
Variety Yield Rank Yield Rank Yield Rank Yield Rank Yield Rank Yield Rank Yield Rank Flower Date Canopy Height
          ——————————- lbs. per  acre ——————————–   days
inches
Control Varieties
Athena 4,084 10 4,632 12 4,407 20 5,401 24 3,469 18 1,991 1 4,605 3 125 60
Ericka 2,865 30 3,559 30 3,354 30 4,476 30 881 30 1,779 4 3,140 29 122 58
Dwarf Essex 3,413 28 3,774 29 4,662 12 5,854 12 1,921 28 1,259 19 3,009 30 125 67
Kansas State University
Griffin 3,781 20 4,345 17 4,075 28 5,570 19 3,499 17 1,314 17 3,881 14 124 58
Surefire (KSUR 1211) 3,841 18 4,535 14 4,438 19 5,834 13 3,523 16 1,406 15 3,310 23 126 65
KS 4675 3,642 23 4,189 20 4,515 15 5,616 16 3,181 21 1,054 26 3,299 24 126 65
KSR 4724.S 3,406 29 3,775 28 4,198 25 5,282 26 3,059 22 973 28 3,147 28 125 62
Photosyntech
Quartz 4,042 12 5,586 4 4,737 10 5,697 14 3,191 20 971 29 4,072 11 126 61
Rubisco Seeds
Edimax CL  4,413  5  6,030  2  5,022  4  5,297  25  4,290  6  1,081  25  4,757  1  126  61
Mercedes 4,933 1 6,085 1 5,821 1 7,389 2 4,747 3 1,188 22 4,367 9 125 64
Phoenix CL 4,636 4 5,879 3 4,742 9 7,144 4 4,964 1 1,212 20 3,873 15 125 62
Plurax CL 4,708 2 5,415 6 5,589 2 7,237 3 4,854 2 1,192 21 3,961 12 122 60
Popular 4,706 3 5,500 5 5,532 3 7,776 1 4,495 4 1,415 14 3,517 18 124 61
Star Specialty Seed, Inc.
Star 915W RR 3,485 26 4,133 21 4,191 26 5,523 20 1,423 29 1,186 23 4,453 4 126 63
Croplan by Winfield
HyCLASS 115W RR  3,444  27  3,917  26  4,000  29  5,470  21  2,154  27  1,542  7  3,581  17  125  61
HyCLASS 225W RR 3,671 22 4,400 16 4,545 14 5,273 27 2,859 23 1,451 12 3,497 21 125 62
HyCLASS 320W RR 3,518 25 3,792 27 4,394 21 5,422 22 2,710 26 1,634 5 3,155 27 126 60
University of Idaho
Amanda 4,006 13 3,987 24 4,498 17 6,975 5 2,768 25 1,423 13 4,385 7 127 62
15.WC.1 3,750 21 4,509 15 4,268 24 5,576 18 2,857 24 1,048 27 4,244 10 126 61
05.WC.6.4.3 IMI 3,592 24 4,051 22 4,111 27 5,235 28 3,680 13 1,272 18 3,201 26 126 63
05.WC.15.7.5 IMI 3,835 19 4,260 19 4,567 13 5,655 15 3,596 14 1,497 10 3,434 22 128 65
10WN.60.1.10 3,965 14 4,012 23 4,484 18 6,154 10 3,385 19 1,816 2 3,941 13 127 66
03WC.6.202.3 4,209 8 4,780 9 4,833 8 6,847 6 4,109 8 1,183 24 3,500 20 126 66
03WC.13.305.2 4,377 6 4,782 8 4,724 11 6,571 7 3,967 11 1,811 3 4,404 6 126 64
13.WC.19.9 4,339 7 4,660 11 4,967 6 6,212 9 4,251 7 1,507 9 4,435 5 127 65
13.WC.20.3 4,122 9 4,589 13 4,499 16 6,310 8 3,973 10 1,529 8 3,834 16 125 63
13.WC.34.5 3,946 16 4,710 10 4,985 5 4,968 29 4,023 9 1,478 11 3,514 19 126 63
13.WC.107.6 3,941 17 4,264 18 4,837 7 6,063 11 4,366 5 907 30 3,207 25 126 63
Durola Rapeseed 4,049 11 4,945 7 4,301 23 5,416 23 3,851 12 1,396 16 4,384 8 125 62
05.WI.45.2.2 IMI Rapeseed 3,963 15 3,974 25 4,316 22 5,592 17 3,588 15 1,605 6 4,704 2 125 60
Mean 3,956 4,569 4,587 5,928 3,454 1,371 3,827 125 62
LSD (p=0.05) 326 771 506 1295 703 N.S. 1,106 0.4 2.0
C.V. (%) 14.7 12.0 8.8 12.6 14.5 33.8 20.6 0.3 3.2

 

The Pendleton site was affected by severe Sclerotina white mold/stem rot, and the Hermiston site had severe lodging due to a heavy rain in June.

Seeding Dates:

  • Odessa, WA – Sept 13, 2017
  • Moscow, ID – Aug 10, 2017
  • Genesee, ID – Early – Aug 10, 2017
  • Genesee, ID – Late – Sept 27, 2017
  • Pendleton, OR – Sept 18, 2017
  • Herminston, OR – Sept 28, 2018

Note that the Genesee-Late seeding date is much later than traditional/optimal, but the Oregon seeding dates are traditional for those sites.

 


 

2018 University of Idaho PNW Spring Canola & Rapeseed Variety Trial results including mean yield (lbs. per acre) and rank at all sites, yield by site (lbs./acre), mean flower date

at Moscow and Genesee (days after planting), and mean plant canopy height at Moscow and Genesee (inches).

Mean Yield and rank at all sites Yield by location
Varieties Tested   Bonners Ferry, ID Moscow, ID
Genesee, ID
Craigmont, ID
Davenport, WA
Fairfield, WA
Dayton, WA
Pendleton, OR
Flower Start
Plant Height
Control Varieties lbs per acre rank ——————————————– lbs per acre —————————————- days inches
Westar 2,040 35 1,901 2,483 3,550 2,009 1,376 1,076 2,890 1,032 49 45
Profit 1,996 38 2,014 2,248 3,289 2,051 1,014 1,209 2,836 1,303 49 46
Goldrush 1,791 40 1,814 2,151 2,579 2,582 1,408 1,144 1,926 725 39 40
BASF InVigor Canola
InVigor L140P LL 2,630 8 3,216 2,816 4,107 2,912 1,505 1,836 3,166 1,481 51 49
InVigor L233P LL 2,667 5 3,067 2,613 4,192 3,105 1,675 1,675 3,295 1,715 50 49
Brett Young Seeds
5545 CL 2,647 6 3,575 2,779 4,340 2,498 1,532 1,394 3,581 1,476 51 50
4187 RR 2,460 18 3,531 2,391 3,881 2,206 1,232 1,340 3,495 1,606 54 51
6074 RR 2,525 15 3,581 2,450 3,914 2,528 1,570 1,416 3,388 1,351 52 48
6090 RR 2,374 20 3,083 2,344 4,168 2,521 1,256 1,027 3,460 1,135 53 56
Canterra Seeds
CS2500 CL 2,583 12 3,424 2,818 4,172 2,676 1,443 1,236 3,691 1,204 51 50
Cargill Global Edible Oil Solutions
V32-1 CL 2,244 23 2,921 2,371 3,579 2,310 1,198 1,397 2,966 1,212 52 48
11H4030 RR 2,609 11 3,066 2,780 3,867 2,974 1,760 1,432 3,271 1,721 45 41
Nutrien Ag Solutions
DG 200 CL 2,631 7 3,517 2,653 4,084 2,622 1,807 1,241 3,607 1,515 52 50
DG 533G RR 2,492 16 2,943 2,622 4,239 2,553 1,387 1,511 3,248 1,432 51 47
DG 540G RR 2,480 17 2,930 2,995 3,987 2,440 1,442 1,550 3,116 1,379 51 48
Croplan by WinField United
HyCLASS 730 RR 2,570 13 2,999 2,962 4,386 2,789 1,658 1,443 3,271 1,050 47 45
HyCLASS 930 RR 2,443 19 2,695 2,646 4,037 2,725 1,719 1,710 3,311 697 46 45
HyCLASS 955 RR 2,611 9 2,724 2,568 4,714 2,952 1,677 1,562 3,351 1,339 48 45
DEKALB
DKL 35-23 RR 2,755 2 3,259 2,955 4,569 3,142 1,672 1,654 3,455 1,336 48 46
DKL 70-10 RR 2,609 10 3,194 2,950 4,327 2,725 1,732 1,324 3,511 1,109 49 47
Photosyntech
NCC101S 2,794 1 2,067 3,111 4,226 3,482 2,138 1,975 3,575 1,777 44 44
NCC.1825/8-S 2,696 4 2,844 2,831 4,150 2,950 2,000 1,784 3,300 1,706 47 43
Rubisco Seeds
Atomic TT 1,771 41 1,745 1,723 2,994 2,090 900 1,197 2,570 952 48 42
Trapper 2,550 14 2,522 2,824 4,067 3,142 1,630 1,360 3,315 1,539 45 44
Star Specialty Seed
Star 402 RR 2,701 3 3,400 2,611 4,296 3,029 1,731 1,790 3,547 1,207 48 47
University of Idaho Canola
Empire 2,226 24 1,901 2,713 3,844 2,584 1,409 1,415 2,889 1,049 47 41
07SC27.19.B3 1,933 39 1,861 1,857 3,215 1,979 1,317 1,225 2,889 1,117 49 45
07.IR.7.8.8.7 2,066 33 2,150 2,288 3,528 2,296 1,158 1,218 2,782 1,109 49 47
14.SC.4.8 2,080 32 1,566 2,562 3,740 2,455 1,380 1,052 2,719 1,165 48 44
14.SC.81.5 2,312 22 2,102 2,625 3,941 2,485 1,551 1,378 3,030 1,384 47 43
14.SC.88.11 2,124 29 1,908 2,753 3,690 2,538 1,078 1,047 2,876 1,101 51 48
14.SC.96.9 2,223 26 1,927 2,393 3,757 2,505 1,577 1,195 3,002 1,431 49 44
14.SC.157.9 2,123 30 1,971 2,454 3,327 2,427 1,414 1,221 2,885 1,284 49 43
University of Idaho Industrial Rapeseed
Gem 2,002 37 1,539 2,619 3,234 2,332 1,300 1,290 2,929 773 47 44
07.SI.8.A10 2,225 25 1,965 2,648 3,495 2,641 1,794 1,115 2,983 1,157 45 41
07.IR.1.5.4.5 2,051 34 1,824 2,037 3,671 2,416 1,375 1,324 2,817 947 48 47
14.SC.5.7 2,039 36 2,010 2,233 3,325 2,390 1,363 1,519 2,713 756 48 44
14.SC.94.16 2,327 21 2,100 2,965 3,974 2,740 1,416 1,355 2,970 1,092 47 44
14.SC.156.10 2,159 27 2,539 2,137 3,650 2,451 1,549 1,091 2,823 1,035 48 43
10SN27.A7.9.10 2,095 31 1,899 2,300 3,607 2,409 1,322 1,280 2,784 1,161 45 41
10SN27.A7.9.14 2,157 28 1,902 2,763 3,632 2,316 1,432 1,153 2,794 1,267 45 42
Mean 2,337 2,517 2,562 3,838 2,585 1,485 1,370 3,098 1,240 48 46
LSD (p = 0.05 ) 138 521 443 453 276 337 355 317 412 0.7 2.1
C.V. (%) 13.7 14.9 12.4 8.5 7.7 16.3 18.6 7.3 23.9 1.6 4.7